Just like a batting practice fastball, Malcolm Gladwell’s writing hits me right in the wheelhouse. He has a really unique way of getting his point across which inevitably causes me to reevaluate the way I look at things.
His newest book is no exception except that it’s not a “book” but a compilation of articles he has written for The New Yorker. Please do yourself a favor and give it a look.
To get you started here is an excerpt from one of the articles titled “Blowup”. The article is a discussion of risk, the psychology of decision making, and accumulated errors based around the Challenger explosion. It is concluded with this paragraph and was originally published in 1996.
What accidents like the Challenger should teach us is that we have constructed a world in which the potential for high-tech catastrophe is embedded in the fabric of day-to-day life. At some point in the future-for the most mundane of reasons, and with the very best of intentions-a NASA spacecraft will again go down in flames. We should at least admit this to ourselves now. And if we cannot-if the possibility is too much to bear-then our only option is to start thinking about getting rid of things like space shuttles altogether.
Entitlement Creep
That was what FDR had to say when talking about Social Security, the program he signed into law in 1935.
He is described as a visionary who helped save our country from economic ruin by some. By others, he is described as a socialist. Either way, his wisdom is evident in the statement above.
Today, the same descriptions are being made of Barack Obama. If he were still alive, I’d like to think that FDR would be reminding the current president of our inability to “insure one hundred percent of the population against one hundred percent of the hazards and vicissitudes of life.”
The Social Security of today barely resembles the Social Security that FDR enacted. Along the way we have added additional benefits with the attempt to protect more and more people.
I worry the same will happen with our health care reform. I have no problem trying to make health care more accessible and affordable. However, I do have problem with trying protect one hundred percent of the population from one hundred percent of the hazards and vicissitudes of life.
Why? It’s just not possible. And if we begin this journey towards health care reform with that end in mind, we are already doomed to failure and to suffer yet another version of creeping entitlements.
- Social Commentary
on March 25, 2010 at 12:00 pm Leave a Comment